The latest from the right

Based on observation of social media, the latest from climate science deniers appears to be in two areas: backlash against Climate Activist Greta Thunberg, and statements to the effect that science has been wrong about the climate in the past (with the implication that we therefore shouldn’t believe it now).

The first is easy. In this Vox.com article, the author, David Roberts, states that in its typical vile fashion, the right has attempted to use Ms. Thunberg’s mental health against her. But the attempt has backfired. She is patently authentic, direct in a way that is unique among public figures, and not at all subject to coercion.

Thus, we have Greta’s impassioned appeal to the governments of the world through her speech at the United Nations and others, the enormously successful Global Climate Strike that she helped lead, and the miserable failure of attempts to discredit her. Watching it all unfold, and even taking part in the Strike itself, has been more than gratifying.

But we are also now seeing a resurgence of climate-denial talking points to the effect that as late as the 1970s, scientists thought that the earth was cooling, and that even when global warming became widely accepted science, predictions have often been wrong. Let’s break this down a little.

1) Science isn’t always right, and scientists will be the first to admit that as a discipline devoted to understanding and pursuit of knowledge, there have indeed been errors. So yes, before the effect of greenhouse gasses on atmospheric temperatures became widely understood, there were theories about a current ‘ice-age cycle.’ The thing about science is, however, that it’s self-correcting. And we should trust this mechanism. Just because people once thought the earth was the center of the universe does not mean we should disbelieve scientists when they now say that it is not.

2) Some of the "previous science" being brought out now never was. It's a pack of lies. Like the doctored Time Magazine cover and the purported scientific predictions about the polar ice cap melting before its time.

3) Climate science has only existed in its present form for about 35 years. Yes, the climate had been studied before that, but it was only in the 1980s that global temperatures could be measured precisely over time, and that computer models could become powerful enough to become useful. They are more useful now than previously, and they will continue to improve. This is not to say that we should wait to act because the "science isn't complete" yet. Science is never complete. At this point, however, it's certainly complete enough to understand the path forward.

The Right continues to try to muddy the waters of science and the green movement. We’ve lamented it before, but this shouldn’t have ever become political at all. Unfortunately, powerful forces continue to purchase goons on the Right to use as political hacks and spread nonsense. More unfortunately, these forces, such as Exxon and Koch Industries, have resources that are virtually unlimited.

But we, the people, have Greta. And a couple million other Kids.

Climate Strike - September 20, 2019

Debbie and I were proud to attend the Global Climate Strike on September 20, 2019. The strike was organized by young people in the Sunrise Movement and other organizations such as the Sierra Club and 350.org. Greta Thunberg is the spiritual leader of the entire movement, and she is everyone's environmental heroine.

When we first heard of the strike, we made plans to attend the New York City one. Greta would be in attendance, so it promised to be a moving experience. But when local events became organized as well, we decided to attend the Cleveland strike. Although I'm sure we missed a lot of excitement in the Big Apple, the Cleveland one was just fine for us.

We arrived at noon with our signs, and immediately joined a rather small crowd marching around Public Square and chanting. We all stopped when the speakers began, and at that point, the crowd began to build. After a while, a good portion of Public Square was filled with protesters.

I was particularly impressed that many of the great speakers, not to mention the organizers and the protesters were quite young. Many were high school and college students.

And that's the entire point: adults have nearly entirely destroyed the planet's ecosystem. Young people, who will inherit the earth, need to become the catalysts for change. And so they are. And since those of us in my generation have also proved incapable of correcting our madness, maybe the kids can. We only need to stay out of their way.

That's what Debbie and I are doing. Being supportive in every way we know. But we also know we can't be the leaders of the movement. That ship has sailed. We are happy to follow those most affected. And those most enthusiastic.

My Question to the Candidates

CNN is holding a Climate Change Town Hall on Wednesday, September 4 at 5:00 PM EDT. Many of the top Democratic presidential candidates will take part. The Sierra Club asked me if I wanted to submit a question. I did. Here it is:

The Green New Deal or anything like it requires a transformation of our entire economy. Besides Executive Action, major legislation will be required. How will you convince reluctant and even hostile Republicans in Congress to join Democrats and go along? More importantly, how will you convince more of the American people that it’s necessary?